Leave the Bird Bath Out

The Craftsman’s Review
Stories From America’s Workshops, Farms & Front Porches
Advertisement

“Every October folks drain the bird bath and carry it into the garage. That’s the month the cardinals and chickadees start needing it most.” — Why a 71-year-old Ohio foundryman is selling his last bronze bird baths at a special price, before his furnace goes cold for good.

A male cardinal drinking from Cal Renner’s bronze leaf-maiden bird bath on a frosty Ohio morning, a round disc of ice on the grass beside it
Holmes County, Ohio, just after sunrise. Five degrees, and the first customer is already waiting.

At a quarter to seven, with the thermometer on the shed reading five degrees, Cal Renner walks out to the bird bath by his back step. He raps the ice once with his knuckle. It comes out of the bowl in one round piece, like a cookie from a tin. He fills the bowl with water from a jug he keeps by the stove.

Before he is back on the step, a cardinal drops out of the lilac. Then two chickadees. Then a junco. Within twenty minutes, eleven birds have come to that one small bowl of water.

Cal is 71. He poured iron for 38 years at a foundry outside Mansfield, and for the last seven he has cast bronze bird baths in a shed behind his house near Millersburg, in Ohio’s Amish country. Every fall, he hears the same thing from his neighbors.

“Every October folks drain the bird bath and carry it into the garage. That’s the month the cardinals and chickadees start needing it most.”

The January morning a cardinal pecked at the ice for ten minutes

A male cardinal pecking at the frozen water in the bowl of the bronze bird bath on a snowy Ohio farm
The first figure Cal ever cast, in its first winter outside. It took him one morning to understand what he was watching.

Cal does not rush the green color that bronze is known for. Every figure he casts stands outside through one full Ohio winter, and frost and rain do the work. So the first one he ever made spent its first January out by the back step.

One morning that January, at five degrees, he watched a cardinal land on the rim. It pecked at the ice in the bowl. It kept pecking for ten minutes. There was nothing underneath to drink.

“The feeder was full,” Cal says. “Fifty pounds of sunflower seed in the shed. That bird wasn’t hungry. It was thirsty.”

Every creek and puddle in the valley was frozen. Snow does not help much either. A bird has to spend its own body heat to melt it. The next morning Cal knocked the ice out of the bowl and poured in fresh water. He has done it every winter morning since.

Twelve hours, one pour, and a shed that smells of hot sand

Cal Renner working in his small bronze casting shed in Holmes County, Ohio
The old machine shed behind Cal’s house. About four hundred square feet, one window, one furnace.

The shop is an old machine shed with a dirt-and-plank floor. A propane furnace sits behind a wall of firebrick. In winter the shed is the warmest place on the farm. It smells of scorched sand and hot metal, like a match held a little too long.

Cal packs each mold by hand, melts the bronze and pours the whole figure at once: a seated girl in a dress of cast leaves, the hem of her dress held up to form a shallow bowl. “The pour takes ten seconds,” he says, tapping a mold with one knuckle. “It’s everything around it that takes the day.”

From the first shovel of sand to the last pass with the file, one figure takes him about twelve hours.

What seven Ohio winters taught him about a bird bath

Close-up of the green verdigris patina on the cast bronze leaves of the bird bath
No paint and no chemicals. This green comes from one winter of frost and rain.

Ask Cal why his bird baths stay out all year and he will give you four reasons.

  • “The Frost-Proof Pour”: Each figure is one solid casting of bronze, with no seams and nothing glued. Concrete and ceramic bird baths soak up water, and when it freezes they crack. That is why folks learned to bring them in. “Bronze doesn’t drink water, so it has nothing to crack it.”
  • “The Shallow-Sip Basin”: The bowl is shallow, about a pint of water. In summer a chickadee can stand in it safely. In winter the ice lifts out in one round piece with a single tap, and fresh water goes right back in.
  • “The One-Winter Patina”: Every figure has already spent a whole winter outside before it leaves Cal’s yard. The soft green is the proof. It has been through the frost once, and it came through fine.
  • “The Layered-Leaf Canopy”: The cast leaves of the dress are layered like shingles. In spring and fall, rain runs down them and into the bowl, so it tops itself up between visits.

One thing Cal says plainly: the bowl is not heated. On a cold morning, fresh water stays open for about an hour before it starts to freeze again. “That hour is when they come,” he says. “You fill it with your coffee, they drink with theirs.”

The letter from Fort Wayne that his niece read twice

Cal’s weathered hands pouring water into the bronze bowl at first light
First light, a jug of water, and a bowl that never comes inside.

Cal does not own a computer. His niece Dana, a teacher in Wooster, set up his little shop online and reads him the mail at his kitchen table.

Last February a retired mail carrier in Fort Wayne, Indiana, wrote to him. She had been about to carry her bird bath into the garage for the winter. Then she remembered what Cal said about the cold months and left it by her kitchen window.

“She wrote that on the coldest morning of the year she counted fourteen birds at it before eight o’clock,” Cal says. “Cardinals, chickadees, a nuthatch hanging upside down off the rim. I had Dana read that one twice.”

The cold gets into his right hand first

Cal Renner in a winter work coat holding one of his last bronze bird baths in his snowy farm yard in Holmes County, Ohio
One of the last ones. Cal wants every one of them outside this winter.

Cal will miss the winter pours most of all. The furnace roaring while snow comes down outside the one window. The bronze glowing orange in the crucible. The quiet when the mold is full.

But three years ago a tremor came into his right hand, and it has not left. In the cold it gets worse. Last August the crucible tipped half an inch it should not have, and the splash left a burn the size of a quarter on his forearm.

“That was the metal telling me. You don’t argue with it twice.”

He started this year with the last of his bronze, enough for sixty-one figures. Today there are 23 left on the bench in the shed. When they are gone, the furnace goes cold for good.

Why he wants the last ones out in the snow, not on a shelf

A row of the last finished bronze leaf-maiden bird baths on a plank bench in Cal’s shed
The bench in the shed. Once it held sixty-one figures. Now there are 23.

A garden gallery would charge several hundred dollars for a solid bronze piece like this. Cal could ask for that, and nobody would blame him.

He doesn’t. “I’ve got my pension and I’ve got the house,” he says. “I don’t need the money. What I want is water standing in more yards this January, where a cardinal can find it.”

So he priced his last 23 at a small part of that, on purpose. He asks only one thing: that each bird bath goes outside and stays there, through the freeze and into spring. Dana tucks a card into every box in his handwriting. It says: “Leave me out all winter.”

While the last 23 are still on the bench: Cal’s hand-cast bronze bird baths, at his special price.

See What’s Left on the Bench

Check availability →

What folks say about Cal’s bird baths

  • ★★★★★

    “Every fall I used to put my old concrete bird bath in the barn. This one stayed out because of the card. On a morning at six below I had cardinals and juncos at it before I had my boots on.”

    Sharon K., Findlay, OH
  • ★★★★★

    “Two winters outside now and not a crack anywhere. The ice pops right out of the bowl with one tap, just like he says.”

    Dale M., Erie, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “Bought it for my mother for Christmas. She keeps a kettle by the back door now and fills it every morning. She calls the chickadees her regulars.”

    Laura B., Bloomington, IN

Three questions folks ask before the last ones go

Where can I get one?

Only here, on this page. Cal’s bird baths are not sold on Amazon, in garden centers or on any marketplace. His niece set up this one shop for him.

How long will they be available?

Only while they last. There are 23 left right now, and Cal can no longer pour new ones. When the bench is empty, that is the end of it.

Can I try one with no risk?

Yes. Every bird bath comes with a 30-day guarantee. If it isn’t what you hoped, send a short email and return it. No hassle.

The creeks freeze first. One of Cal’s last bird baths can be standing in your yard before they do.

Check Availability

Limited quantity — hand-cast in solid bronze

More from folks who left theirs out

  • ★★★★★

    “My husband wanted to bring it in for winter. I showed him the card. It stayed by the feeder, and now he’s the one out there with the jug every morning.”

    Janice R., Lancaster, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “With snow on her leaves she’s even prettier than in summer. The neighbors stop at the fence to look.”

    Gary T., Ann Arbor, MI
  • ★★★★★

    “Knowing it is one of the last he will ever pour makes it more than a bird bath. It stays out all year now, the way he says it should.”

    Ellen & Roy P., Wooster, OH